PBI for Breast in Situ Carcinoma of Intermediate Low Risk As Local Adjuvant Treatment

Screening and advances in breast imaging led to a continuous increase of Ductal Carcinoma in situ (DCIS) diagnosis. Unfortunately, the management of this specific disease is still debated regarding adjuvant therapy (radiation therapy and endocrine therapy) after breast conserving surgery (BCS).

Four randomized trials have shown a decrease of the local recurrence (LR) using adjuvant radiotherapy with conventional fractionation (50 Gy in 25 fractions). In the early breast cancer trialists' collaborative Group (EBCTCG) overview (7) radiotherapy approximatively halved the ipsilateral breast event (IBE) rate, from 28.1% to 12.9 % at 10 years. Radiotherapy was reported to be effective in reducing the risk of local recurrence in all analyzed patients and tumor characteristics (e.g. age, tumor size, histological grade, comedonecrosis, etc.), but no differences were seen in distant metastases, breast cancer-specific survival, or overall survival between irradiated and un-irradiated patients. Nowadays, progress in diagnosis and a greater attention in achieving negative surgical margins increased the interest in identifying sub groups of patient in which a treatment de-escalation could be possible. Some prospective randomized and non-randomized trials try to define a low-risk cohort in which radiotherapy could be omitted. RTOG 9804 randomized 711 low-intermediate risk patients to RT versus nothing and find that LF rate decreased significantly with the addition of RT.

De-escalation of radiation therapy treatment could be done with partial breast irradiation (PBI). In modern era 7 randomized trials analyzed the efficacy of PBI versus whole breast RT in low-risk patients with early stage breast cancer, using different techniques. Those studies drive ESTRO and ASTRO to endorse the use of PBI out of clinical trials. In general, PBI involves treating the surgical cavity with a 1- to 2-cm margin, thus reducing the volume of treated breast tissue by up to 50% using various methods. Technical approaches of PBI include multicatheter interstitial brachytherapy, balloon catheter brachytherapy, external 3-D conformal external beam radiotherapy (3D-CRT), intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT) and intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT). Park et al. reported a retrospective study on 53 patients treated with MammoSite brachytherapy or 3D-CRT, with a Three-year actuarial ipsilateral breast tumor recurrence was 2%. Becherini et al. analyzed the long-term efficacy and safety results of the series of 22 patients with DCIS enrolled in the accelerated PBI arm of the APBI-IMRT-Florence phase 3 trial and found 5- and 10-year local recurrence, distant metastasis-free survival, and breast cancer-specific survival of 100%.

To date, data from available literature supports the hypothesis that PBI is a safe well tolerated therapy that appears to be equivalent to WBI in terms of efficacy and ultimate breast cosmesis in infiltrating carcinoma. Data on DCIS are missing.

Based on this background, we designed a study to evaluate 5-year Local Control rate of Partial Breast Irradiated (PBI) using external beam radiotherapy (3D-CRT, VMAT-RA, Tomotherapy or Cyberknife) or brachytherapy in a selected group of women with low-intermediate DCIS.