AzTrials
AzTrials

Oral and Maxillofacial ConditionsPhase 2NCT07921082

Effectiveness of Oxitard Gel Versus Physiotherapeutic and Pharmacological Interventions in Alleviating Oral Submucous Fibrosis: A Phase-II Randomized Control Trial

A Phase 2 study testing Herbal Formulation, Shekar's appliance and Multivitamin/Mineral supplements in people with Oral and Maxillofacial Conditions, run by Dow University of Health Sciences at 1 site in Pakistan.

Not yet recruiting

Opening soon. The study is approved but enrolment has not started yet. Sites may already take enquiries.

Sites and contacts
Official record
Search all trials

Trial summary

Effectiveness of Oxitard Gel Versus Physiotherapeutic and Pharmacological Interventions in Alleviating Oral Submucous Fibrosis: A Phase-II Randomized Control Trial Background Oral Submucous Fibrosis (OSMF) is a chronic, potentially malignant disorder of the oral mucosa. Read more about this study

Who is it for?
Ages 18 years and older
Conditions the study is for
Oral and Maxillofacial Conditions
What is being tested?
Herbal Formulation, Shekar's appliance and Multivitamin/Mineral supplements
Could I receive a placebo?
No, everyone receives an active treatment
How many people
20 participants
Where
1 sitePakistan
Study dates
15 Nov 2026to 28 Feb 2027
Phase
Phase 2
Are there results?
Not yet: the study is under way

Key requirements

Who can take part, as listed by the sponsor. Only the study team can confirm whether you are eligible, so take this list to your doctor.

  • Ages 18 years and older
  • All sexes
  • No healthy volunteers
  • Adult, Older adult

Who may be able to join

  • Patients diagnosed with OSMF who present with limited mouth opening, burning sensation, fibrotic bands and blanched mucosa.
  • Patients in Haider et al. Clinical Stage 1 or 2 (faucial bands only, or faucial plus buccal bands) and Functional Stage A or B (mouth opening of 11 mm or more).

Who cannot join

  • Patients whose OSMF has a leukoplakic, erythroplakic or speckled appearance, has non-healing ulcers, or is suspected of malignancy on clinical examination or biopsy.
  • Patients with any temporomandibular joint (TMJ) dysfunction. Patients with psychiatric disorders. Patients with other oral lesions that cause burning, such as aphthous stomatitis, burning mouth syndrome and vesiculobullous diseases.
  • Patients with hypersensitivity to any ingredient of the gel or to any vitamin

Trial locations and contacts

1 site in 1 country. Contact the study team or a site near you to ask about taking part.

Ramsha Azhar, BDS, MDS Resident contact

0092 21 111 113 847

ramsha.azhar@duhs.edu.pk

Pakistan1 site
  • Dow University of Health Sciences

    Karachi, Sindh, 74200

    Salik Rasool, M.Phil, 0092 21 38771000, salik.rasool@duhs.edu.pk

    Amynah Charania, Mphil, PhD Scholar, 0092 21 38771000, p.didc@duhs.edu.pk

Other trials in Pakistan

About this study

Official title: A Double Blind Randomized Control Trial of Shekhar's Appliance and Novel Herbal Gel for Non-surgical Management of Oral Submucous Fibrosis.

Effectiveness of Oxitard Gel Versus Physiotherapeutic and Pharmacological Interventions in Alleviating Oral Submucous Fibrosis: A Phase-II Randomized Control Trial

Background Oral Submucous Fibrosis (OSMF) is a chronic, potentially malignant disorder of the oral mucosa. It causes progressively restricted mouth opening, reduced tongue protrusion with depapillation, submucosal fibrosis, blanching and loss of mucosal elasticity, and a shrunken uvula. It most often affects the buccal mucosa, palate and retromolar region, followed by the faucial pillars and pharynx. It is most common in South Asia. Areca nut chewing is the main cause, and commercial products such as gutka, pan masala and mawa add to the burden. Iron, vitamin B12 and folate deficiencies and capsaicin from chillies may also contribute.

Read more

Irritants in areca nut and chillies trigger a juxta-epithelial inflammatory reaction. This shows first as burning, then vesicles, then ulceration. The epithelium becomes atrophic and poorly vascularised, so it heals poorly and scars. That scarring produces the fibrosis that restricts mouth opening, tongue movement and cheek flexibility. Treatment begins with stopping the habit. Early and intermediate cases are managed without surgery, usually with oral physiotherapy as an add-on.

Operational Definition (Haider et al.)

Clinical staging: Stage 1 is faucial bands only, Stage 2 is faucial and buccal bands, and Stage 3 is faucial, buccal and labial bands.

Functional staging: Stage A is mouth opening of 20 mm or more, Stage B is 11-19 mm, and Stage C is 10 mm or less.

Aim and Objectives

The study compares conventional treatment (physiotherapy exercises plus multivitamins) with contemporary treatment (a novel herbal gel and Shekar's intraoral appliance) in OSMF patients. Its objectives are:

Record sociodemographic and clinical features to categorise patients. Assess how well the herbal gel works. Assess how well Shekar's appliance works. Compare both contemporary treatments with conventional therapy.

Hypotheses

Null: there is no difference between conventional and contemporary treatments. Alternate: there is a significant difference between them.

Methodology

Design: pilot randomised controlled trial. Setting: Department of Oral Medicine, Dow International Dental College (DIDC), Karachi. Patients come from DIDC Hospital and Dr. Ishrat-ul-Ibad Khan Institute of Oral Health Sciences.

Inclusion: OSMF patients with limited mouth opening, burning, fibrotic bands and blanched mucosa, in Haider Clinical Stages 1-2 and Functional Stages A-B.

Exclusion: leukoplakic, erythroplakic or speckled lesions, non-healing ulcers or suspected malignancy; TMJ dysfunction; psychiatric disorders; other lesions that cause burning; and hypersensitivity to any ingredient of the gel or vitamins.

Sample and allocation: 5 patients per group, 20 in total. The size was calculated in OpenEpi (95% confidence, 80% power). Patients are recruited by consecutive sampling and assigned to groups by a computer-generated random sequence.

Herbal gel: made by Nutrimed Laboratories. It contains 1% each of Nigella sativa, tulsi, aloe vera, curcumin and lycopene, plus 0.1% vitamin E, in a carbomer 974P base.

Data Collection and Blinding

The study needs IRB approval from DUHS, and every participant gives written informed consent. Oral Medicine staff who are not on the research team do the examinations. A dental assistant keeps the group allocation sealed until the results are complete. Participants are not told which treatment they receive. The outcomes are:

Mouth opening: measured between the incisors with a vernier caliper Burning sensation: Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) Cheek flexibility: measured at rest and with cheeks blown; the difference is recorded Tongue protrusion: in mm Mucosal colour: digital photographs Complete Blood Count: at the start and end of the study

Intervention Groups

Group 1: physiotherapy 3 times a day for 30 minutes, plus Pentovit H twice daily.

Group 2: physiotherapy plus the herbal gel 3 times a day, with nothing to eat or drink for 30 minutes after each application.

Group 3: Shekar's appliance 3 times a day for 15 minutes, plus Pentovit H. Group 4: Shekar's appliance 3 times a day for 15 minutes, plus the herbal gel 3 times a day.

Patients log their compliance on record sheets that don't name their treatment.

Follow-up, Duration and Analysis Patients are reviewed every 15 days for 3 months (6 visits), with a final CBC at the end. The study will take 9-12 months. Paired t-tests will measure change within each group, and unpaired t-tests will compare the groups, with p < 0.05 counted as significant.

Read the detailed description

Effectiveness of Oxitard Gel Versus Physiotherapeutic and Pharmacological Interventions in Alleviating Oral Submucous Fibrosis: A Phase II Randomized Control Trial

  1. Introduction Oral Submucous Fibrosis (OSMF) is a potentially malignant condition that can take a debilitating turn if it is not managed in due course. It is a chronic, insidious and disabling disease of the oral mucosa. It is characterised by progressively restricted mouth opening, reduced tongue protrusion with depapillation of the tongue, fibrosis of the submucosal tissues, blanching and loss of elasticity of the oral mucosa, and a shrunken uvula (1). As the disease advances, these changes interfere with the most basic oral functions, including eating, speaking, swallowing and maintaining oral hygiene. The sites most frequently involved in OSMF are the buccal mucosa, the palate and the retromolar region. These are followed by the faucial pillars and the pharynx (2). Involvement of the soft palate and the faucial pillars can affect speech and swallowing. Involvement of the buccal mucosa produces the vertical fibrotic bands that are the classic clinical sign of the disease, and that progressively limit both mouth opening and cheek flexibility. 1.1 Epidemiology OSMF is most prevalent in South Asian countries. It is especially common in India, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, Pakistan and Nepal. It is also reported from Taiwan, China and the Pacific Islands, with sporadic cases among other Asian populations (25). Its geographical distribution closely follows the cultural practice of chewing areca nut and its commercial products. Migration of South Asian communities has also led to cases being reported in other parts of the world. In Pakistan, and particularly in a large urban centre such as Karachi, the easy availability and low cost of areca nut products make OSMF a significant and growing public health concern. 1.2 Aetiology The literature shows that chewing areca nut is the most prevalent cause of OSMF. However, the disease is multifactorial. Iron deficiency, vitamin B12 and folate deficiency, and capsaicin (the active component of chilli peppers) may all play an important role in its progression (4). Nutritional deficiencies are thought to impair the repair capacity of the oral mucosa, making it more vulnerable to the irritants it is repeatedly exposed to. The sudden increase in commercially available modifications of areca nut, namely gutka, pan masala and mawa, also plays a pivotal role in the development of OSMF (1). These products are cheap, attractively packaged and easy to carry. Their use has spread to younger age groups, which helps explain why OSMF is now increasingly seen in adolescents and young adults. 1.3 Classification Numerous classification systems are routinely used for the clinical, functional and histopathological staging of OSMF. One of the most commonly used systems was introduced by Haider et al. In this system, clinical staging is based on the location of fibrotic bands, and functional staging is based on the range of mouth opening (7). This classification is simple to apply at the chairside, requires no special equipment beyond a measuring instrument, and directly relates the disease stage to the patient's functional limitation. For these reasons it has been adopted for the present study. 1.4 Pathogenesis While the functional classification gives a clear indication of the manifestations of OSMF, the root cause of these manifestations lies in the juxta-epithelial inflammatory reaction caused by soluble irritants present in areca nut and chillies (8). A burning sensation is the first sign of inflammation. This is followed by the formation of vesicles, which leads to ulceration of the oral mucosa (8). The normal epithelium is gradually replaced by an atrophic epithelium with reduced vascularity. This leads to defective healing and scar formation (8). The combination of these factors encourages fibrosis, which can be called the hallmark feature of OSMF. Fibrosis in turn leads to restricted mouth opening, reduced tongue protrusion and reduced cheek flexibility (8). Because the process is progressive and largely irreversible once dense fibrosis is established, early intervention is essential to preserve function and to reduce the risk of malignant change. 1.5 Current management Over the years, various treatment modalities have been used for OSMF. The very first step when a patient is diagnosed is habit control. This means immediate cessation of the consumption of betel nut and of products involving pan, tobacco and betel nut chewing. Without habit cessation, no other treatment can be expected to produce lasting benefit. For patients in the early or intermediate stages, a non-surgical approach is preferred. These patients are encouraged to perform mouth opening exercises, including exercises with devices made from acrylic plates. Oral physiotherapy does help to improve mouth opening, but it is usually given as an adjunctive therapy rather than as a stand-alone treatment. Medical therapy, including vitamins, antioxidants and anti-inflammatory agents, is commonly combined with physiotherapy. 1.6 Purpose of the study The mainstay of this study is to test non-invasive contemporary and conventional approaches to improve the declining quality of life that comes with the various manifestations of OSMF. The study compares conventional treatment, consisting of mouth opening exercises and multivitamin therapy, with contemporary treatment, consisting of a novel topical herbal gel and a novel intraoral physiotherapy device called Shekar's appliance. All four treatment combinations are non-invasive, affordable and suitable for use by the patient at home.
  2. Operational Definitions 2.1 Oral Submucous Fibrosis Oral Submucous Fibrosis is an insidious disease that may affect the entire oral cavity and can also extend to the pharynx (7). OSMF can be classified in various ways. Haider et al. differentiated presenting patients both clinically and functionally, in order to distinguish between the various levels of disease progression (7). For this study, a patient is considered to have OSMF when the diagnosis has been made in the Department of Oral Medicine on the basis of history and clinical examination, including palpable fibrotic bands, blanching of the mucosa and restricted mouth opening. 2.2 Clinical staging (Haider et al.) Clinical staging is based on the presence and location of fibrotic bands in the oral cavity (7). Clinical stage Fibrotic bands present Stage 1 Faucial bands only Stage 2 Faucial and buccal bands Stage 3 Faucial, buccal and labial bands 2.3 Functional staging (Haider et al.) Functional staging is based on the measurement of interincisal mouth opening (7). Functional stage Mouth opening Stage A 20 mm or more Stage B 11-19 mm Stage C 10 mm or less 2.4 Outcome variables
  • Mouth opening: the maximum interincisal distance, in millimetres, between the incisal edges of the upper and lower central incisors, measured with a vernier caliper (4).
  • Burning sensation: the patient's self-reported intensity of burning, recorded on a 10-point Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), where 0 means no burning and 10 means the worst burning imaginable (4).
  • Cheek flexibility: the difference, in millimetres, between the distance from the angle of the mouth (V1) to a point one-third of the way along a line from the angle of the mouth to the tragus of the ear (V2), measured first at rest and then with the cheeks blown out (4).
  • Tongue protrusion: the distance, in millimetres, from the incisal edges of the lower anterior teeth to the tip of the protruded tongue, measured from the lateral aspect (4).
  • Mucosal colour and blanching: the appearance of the oral mucosa, recorded by standardised digital photographs and compared visually between visits.
  • Conventional treatment: oral physiotherapy exercises and/or oral multivitamin therapy (Pentovit H).
  • Contemporary treatment: the novel topical herbal gel and/or Shekar's intraoral physiotherapy appliance.
  • Compliance: adherence to the allotted regimen, as recorded by the patient on the study record sheet.
  1. Literature Review 3.1 Nature and malignant potential of OSMF OSMF is a debilitating chronic disease characterised by inflammation. It leads to progressive fibrosis of the submucosal tissues, resulting in rigidity and limited mouth opening, and thereby negatively affects the patient's quality of life (1). OSMF is a precancerous condition with one of the highest potentials among oral potentially malignant disorders to turn malignant, at around 7-13% (2). This makes early diagnosis, habit cessation and regular follow-up essential, not only for restoring function but also for the timely detection of malignant change. OSMF is most commonly seen in South Asian countries. It occurs across a wide age range, most commonly between 16 and 35 years, although it has been reported in children as young as five years (1, 3). Its occurrence in young people means that the disease often affects individuals during their most productive years, with consequences for their nutrition, social life and ability to work. 3.2 Classification and staging The most widely used classification for the clinical and functional diagnosis and staging of OSMF is the one developed by Haider et al. According to this classification, a patient presenting with faucial bands only is considered clinical Stage 1. A patient with faucial and buccal bands is classified as clinical Stage 2. A patient with faucial, buccal and labial bands together is regarded as clinical Stage 3 (7). The functional staging of OSMF is based on the range of mouth opening. Stage A is for patients with a mouth opening of 20 mm or more. Stage B is for patients with a mouth opening of 11-19 mm. Stage C is for patients with a mouth opening of 10 mm or less (7). Taken together, the clinical and functional stages help the clinician choose an appropriate treatment and monitor the patient's response over time. 3.3 General principles of management When a patient is diagnosed with OSMF, the first step is cessation of the habit, effective immediately. The treatment of OSMF then correlates with the clinical and functional stage of the disease. There has never been a standardised treatment protocol that dentists all over the world follow after diagnosing OSMF. Physiotherapy has evolved to become the primary treatment offered to patients. For the most part, OSMF is managed symptomatically and empirically (26). This lack of a standard protocol is one of the main reasons why comparative clinical trials of different treatment modalities are needed. 3.4 Physiotherapy Treatment for patients diagnosed with Stage 1, or mild, OSMF relies heavily on physiotherapy with regular check-ups (31). These patients are asked to perform various mouth opening exercises. These include the tongue blade exercise, tongue-in-cheek push, side tongue stretch, cheek puff, pucker, the "O" exercise, lip hold, and the up-and-down tongue stretch, used as an adjunct to other treatments to improve mouth opening (27). Physiotherapy works by repeatedly stretching the fibrotic tissue and the muscles of mastication, which helps to maintain and gradually improve the range of movement. The main limitation of physiotherapy is that it depends heavily on patient motivation and compliance. Exercises must be performed several times a day over months, and many patients stop once the initial discomfort sets in or when improvement is slow. Intraoral appliances, such as Shekar's appliance, have been developed to make physiotherapy more effective, more standardised and easier for patients to perform. 3.5 Pharmacological treatment Apart from physiotherapy, pharmacological treatment modalities include anti-inflammatory drugs such as corticosteroids, vitamins, micronutrients, and antifibrotic agents such as HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors (26). Intralesional injectables, including dexamethasone, triamcinolone and hyaluronidase, have also been used. Multivitamin and micronutrient supplementation is widely prescribed because nutritional deficiencies are believed to contribute to the progression of the disease. 3.6 Ayurvedic and herbal treatment Ayurvedic medicine has played a large part in the treatment of OSMF and offers a more holistic approach. Oxitard, an Ayurvedic medicine containing various herbal extracts, has been shown to be effective in improving mouth opening and burning sensation (28). A study conducted by Patil S. et al. showed significant improvement in mouth opening, burning sensation, tongue protrusion, pain associated with the lesion, and difficulty in swallowing and speech in patients treated with Oxitard capsules (28). Many studies have also used lycopene to treat OSMF. Lycopene is an antioxidant that works by scavenging free radicals and suppressing them physically and chemically (29). This protects cells from damage caused by highly reactive oxygen species (29). Herbal extracts have also been widely tested in patients with OSMF. These include aloe vera, curcumin, turmeric and tulsi. Studies have shown that after application of aloe vera gel, there was a change in collagen content (23). It is a simple and safe treatment modality when combined with cessation of the habit (23). Curcumin is a natural anti-inflammatory compound that disrupts the cell cycle and impedes the proliferation of cells (23). It also decreases connective tissue growth factor, which is associated with both the onset and the progression of OSMF (23). 3.7 Intralesional injections Patients diagnosed with clinical Stage 2, or moderate, OSMF are commonly treated with injectables, and a combination of corticosteroids and hyaluronidase has been used (31). Injections of placental extract, colloidal iodine, interferon-gamma and micronutrients have also been reported (31). While injections can produce measurable improvement, they are painful, require repeated clinic visits, and carry a risk of local complications. This makes them less acceptable to many patients. 3.8 Surgical treatment The most severe cases, clinical Stage 3 OSMF, are usually treated surgically (31). The simplest surgical procedure is primary excision of the fibrous bands (31). Other operations include coronoidotomy, coronoidectomy, and use of the buccal pad of fat as a graft to cover the intraoral defects (31). Other surgical options include collagen membrane, split skin graft, tongue flaps, nasolabial flaps, and an oral stent to prevent secondary scarring and relapse (31). Surgery is invasive, costly and requires hospital admission, and relapse due to fresh scar formation remains a recognised problem. 3.9 Newer modalities Recent developments have led to the use of Electroson (an ultrasound device), laser therapy and cryotherapy as treatment modalities. Vijayakumar M. et al. conducted a study in which all patients were treated with ultrasound together with intraoral manual kneading of the buccal area, to stretch the fibrotic bands within the limits of the patient's pain tolerance (30). Cryotherapy was given both before and after treatment for 5-7 minutes (30, 32). These approaches are promising, but they require specialised equipment and are not widely available in low-resource settings. 3.10 Gap in the literature The treatment modalities described above are well established. However, most of them are invasive, and physiotherapy is the only treatment that is truly patient-friendly. All the other interventions also carry a high cost. What is needed now is a non-invasive intervention that is both patient-friendly and cost-effective. This study addresses that need by combining known herbal extracts into a single gel formulation that patients can easily apply themselves and can afford. It also evaluates a new physiotherapy appliance, and directly compares both against conventional treatment within the same randomised trial.
  2. Rationale There are various treatment modalities for OSMF, but there is no agreed treatment protocol. The management of OSMF depends on its clinical and functional stage (33). Many patients would rather accept a compromised quality of life than go through invasive procedures such as repeated intralesional injections or surgery. As a result, a large proportion of patients either delay treatment or abandon it altogether, allowing the disease to progress. The present study therefore uses only non-invasive treatment modalities. These are conventional mouth opening exercises and multivitamin therapy, and the contemporary novel herbal gel and novel physiotherapy device called Shekar's appliance. All four can be used by the patient at home and require no special clinical procedure beyond initial instruction and periodic review. The literature has shown that herbal medicines have profound effects in patients with OSMF (33). Herbal medicines including lycopene, vitamin E, aloe vera, cumin, curcumin and tulsi are rich in antioxidants. Antioxidants act by isolating free oxygen radicals from susceptible molecules (35). They provide an alternative pathway by competing with oxygen molecules, and help repair the damage caused by free radicals (35). Oxidative stress generated by areca nut constituents is thought to contribute to the inflammation and fibrosis seen in OSMF. A topical preparation that delivers several antioxidants directly to the affected mucosa may therefore reduce both symptoms and disease progression. The gel used in this study contains several components that reduce oxidative stress. Combining them in a single topical formulation may produce a greater effect than any single agent alone. This supports the view that antioxidants play an essential role in reducing the manifestations of OSMF, and the study may also add to the literature on future medications for the disease. Shekar's appliance offers a standardised way to perform oral physiotherapy. Compared with conventional exercises using wooden sticks, an appliance may provide more controlled and consistent stretching, and may be easier for patients to use regularly. Comparing it directly with conventional exercises will show whether this advantage translates into better clinical results. Finally, the interventions in this study are cost-effective, easy to dispense and non-invasive. They also lack any noticeable side effects (33). If they prove effective, they could be adopted widely, particularly in low-resource settings such as public sector dental hospitals in Pakistan, where the burden of OSMF is high and access to advanced treatment is limited.
  3. Aim, Objectives and Hypotheses 5.1 Aim The aim of this study is to compare conventional treatment modalities, namely exercises and multivitamin therapy, with contemporary treatment modalities, namely a novel herbal gel and an intraoral appliance called Shekar's appliance, for the management of patients with OSMF.

5.2 Objectives

  1. To assess sociodemographic parameters and clinical symptoms, including mouth opening, burning sensation, cheek extensibility, fibrotic bands and colour of the mucosa, for the categorisation of OSMF patients.
  2. To determine the efficacy of a novel herbal gel, with active ingredients including Nigella sativa, tulsi, curcumin, aloe vera, lycopene and vitamin E, in reducing the severity of OSMF.
  3. To determine the efficacy of a new intraoral appliance, Shekar's appliance, in reducing the severity of OSMF.
  4. To compare the efficacy of the novel herbal gel and the novel intraoral appliance with traditional treatment modalities (stick exercise and multivitamin therapy), to see whether one or both are better than conventional modalities for the treatment of OSMF.

5.3 Hypotheses

  • Null hypothesis (H0): There is no difference between conventional and contemporary treatment modalities in the improvement of mouth opening, burning sensation, cheek flexibility, tongue protrusion and mucosal colour in patients with OSMF.
  • Alternate hypothesis (H1): There is a significant difference between conventional and contemporary treatment modalities in the improvement of mouth opening, burning sensation, cheek flexibility, tongue protrusion and mucosal colour in patients with OSMF.
  1. Materials and Methods 6.1 Study design This is a randomised controlled trial, conducted as a pilot study. A pilot design has been chosen because the herbal gel is a novel formulation and Shekar's appliance has not previously been evaluated in this population. The pilot will provide preliminary data on efficacy, feasibility, patient compliance and acceptability, which can then be used to plan a larger definitive trial.

6.2 Study site The study will be conducted in the Department of Oral Medicine, Dow International Dental College (DIDC), Dow University of Health Sciences (DUHS), Karachi, Pakistan.

6.3 Study population The study population will consist of patients diagnosed with OSMF in the Department of Oral Medicine of Dow International Dental College Hospital and Dr. Ishrat-ul-Ibad Khan Institute of Oral Health Sciences, Karachi. Both institutions receive a large number of patients from across Karachi and neighbouring areas, including many with areca nut and gutka chewing habits.

6.4 Inclusion criteria

  1. Patients diagnosed with OSMF who present with the complaint of limited mouth opening, burning sensation, fibrotic bands and blanched mucosa.
  2. Patients who fall under Haider et al. Clinical Stage 1 or 2 and Functional Stage A or B.

6.5 Exclusion criteria

  1. Patients with OSMF who have a leukoplakic, erythroplakic or speckled appearance, or non-healing ulcers, or who are suspected of malignancy on clinical examination or biopsy.
  2. Patients with any temporomandibular joint (TMJ) dysfunction.
  3. Patients with psychiatric disorders.
  4. Patients presenting with other oral lesions that cause a burning sensation, such as aphthous stomatitis, burning mouth syndrome and vesiculobullous diseases.
  5. Patients with hypersensitivity to any component of the gel or to any vitamin. These criteria ensure that improvement in the outcome measures can be attributed to the study interventions. Patients with suspected malignancy are excluded so that they can be referred immediately for appropriate investigation and management. Patients with TMJ dysfunction are excluded because joint pathology can itself limit mouth opening. Patients with other burning lesions are excluded because these would confound the assessment of burning sensation.

6.6 Sampling technique Eligible patients will be recruited using non-probability consecutive sampling: every patient who meets the inclusion criteria and gives consent during the study period will be enrolled until the required sample size is reached. Enrolled participants will then be randomly allocated to the four study groups, as described in Section 7.3.

6.7 Sample size The sample size was calculated from the parent article using OpenEpi software, with a 95% confidence interval and 80% power (36). The calculated sample size is 5 participants in each group, giving a total of 20 participants across the four groups. Because the follow-up period is three months, some participants may be lost to follow-up. It is therefore advisable to recruit a small number of additional participants to allow for attrition.

6.8 Formulation of the novel herbal gel The gel is produced by Nutrimed Laboratories. Its active ingredients and excipients are listed below.

Component Concentration Active ingredients Nigella sativa 1% Tulsi 1% Aloe vera 1% Curcumin 1% Lycopene 1% Vitamin E 0.1% Carbomer 974P - Rheological (gelling) agent Humectant, stabiliser, preservative, pH adjuster, flavour - Excipients Water- Vehicle The gel base allows the active ingredients to remain in contact with the oral mucosa for a longer period. Patients will be instructed to apply a thin layer to the affected areas with a clean fingertip.

6.9 Shekar's appliance Shekar's appliance is a novel intraoral physiotherapy appliance designed to improve mouth opening in patients with OSMF. It is used to perform assisted oral physiotherapy, in which controlled stretching of the fibrotic tissues and the muscles of mastication is applied in a consistent and repeatable way. Each participant in Groups 3 and 4 will be shown how to insert, use and clean the appliance, and their technique will be checked at each follow-up visit.

6.10 Multivitamin therapy The multivitamin preparation used in this study is Pentovit H, taken orally. Multivitamin therapy is included in the conventional arm because nutritional deficiencies, including deficiencies of iron, vitamin B12 and folate, are believed to contribute to the progression of OSMF (4).

  1. Data Collection Procedure 7.1 Ethical approval and informed consent Ethical approval will be obtained from the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of DUHS before the study begins. Each participant diagnosed with OSMF will be briefed about their condition, the nature and purpose of the study, the treatments involved, and the follow-up schedule, and will be invited to take part in the clinical trial. All participants who agree will be asked to sign a written informed consent form. The consent form will be available in both English and Urdu, and will be explained verbally to participants who cannot read.

7.2 History and clinical examination Each participant will complete a detailed history form covering personal, dental and medical history. This will include the type, frequency and duration of the areca nut, gutka, pan or tobacco habit. A detailed intraoral examination will then be performed by staff of the Department of Oral Medicine who are not part of the research team, so that the study members remain blinded to the identity of the study subjects.

The examination will record the following parameters:

  • Mouth opening: the interincisal distance, measured with a vernier caliper between two fixed points, the incisal edges of the upper and lower central incisors (4).
  • Burning sensation: evaluated using the Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) (4).
  • Cheek flexibility: measured in millimetres between two fixed points, the angle of the mouth (V1) and a point one-third of the distance (V2) along a line connecting the angle of the mouth and the tragus of the ear (4). The first reading is taken with the participant at rest. The second is taken after the participant has been asked to blow out their cheeks. The difference between the two readings gives the cheek flexibility.
  • Tongue protrusion: recorded in millimetres, as the distance from the incisal edges of the lower anterior teeth to the tip of the tongue, measured from the lateral aspect (4).
  • Mucosal colour and blanching: recorded with digital photographs and compared by visual analysis. Photographs will be taken under standardised lighting and from the same positions at each visit, so that they can be compared reliably.
  • Clinical and functional stage: recorded according to Haider et al. (7). Each participant will also be asked to provide a Complete Blood Count (CBC) report at the start of the study, to establish their baseline haematological status, including haemoglobin level.

7.3 Randomisation and allocation concealment Participants will be randomly allocated to four groups (Groups 1, 2, 3 and 4) using a computer-generated random sequence (simple randomisation). The sequence will be prepared by a faculty member of the Department of Oral Medicine (Person A) who is not otherwise involved in the study. The allocation of each participant will be carried out by a dental assistant, recorded on paper, and kept concealed until the results have been completed. Every effort will be made to prevent the research team from learning the characteristics of the study subjects.

7.4 Blinding Participants will not be told which intervention their study group is receiving. Outcome assessment will be carried out by Oral Medicine staff who are outside the research team and unaware of group allocation. The record sheets given to participants will not name the technique or medicine allotted to them. Because the interventions differ visibly (an appliance versus exercises, a gel versus tablets), complete blinding of participants cannot be guaranteed. Blinding of the outcome assessors is therefore the main safeguard against bias.

7.5 Intervention groups Group Physiotherapy component Medication component Group 1 (conventional) Physiotherapy exercises, 3 times daily, 30 minutes per session Pentovit H, twice daily after meals Group 2 Physiotherapy exercises, 3 times daily, 30 minutes per session Herbal gel, 3 times daily Group 3 Shekar's appliance, 3 times daily, 15 minutes per session Pentovit H, twice daily after meals Group 4 (contemporary) Shekar's appliance, 3 times daily, 15 minutes per session Herbal gel, 3 times daily Group 1: Participants will be advised to follow physiotherapy exercises (stick exercise, alphabet exercise, cheek pushing exercise, balloon blowing exercise, finger snap exercise, isometric exercise and hot pack massage) together with multivitamin therapy. Each participant will perform these exercises three times a day for thirty minutes per session. Each participant will take Pentovit H twice daily, in the morning and at night after meals.

Group 2: Participants will be advised to follow the same physiotherapy exercises together with application of the novel herbal gel. Each participant will perform the exercises three times a day for thirty minutes per session. Each participant will also apply the gel three times a day and will avoid eating or drinking for half an hour after each application.

Group 3: Participants will be advised to use the novel intraoral appliance, Shekar's appliance, together with multivitamin therapy. Each participant will use the appliance three times a day for 15 minutes per session. Each participant will take Pentovit H twice daily, in the morning and at night after meals.

Group 4: Participants will be advised to use Shekar's appliance together with application of the novel herbal gel. Each participant will use the appliance three times a day for 15 minutes per session. Each participant will also apply the gel three times a day and will avoid eating or drinking for half an hour after each application.

All participants, regardless of group, will be counselled at every visit to stop the areca nut, gutka, pan and tobacco habit completely.

7.6 Compliance Each participant will be given a record sheet on which to log their daily adherence to the allotted regimen. The record sheet will not name the technique or medicine allotted to the participant. The research team will review the record sheet at each visit, and participants who are not following the regimen will be counselled and encouraged.

7.7 Follow-up Each participant will be recalled every 15 days over a period of three months, giving a total of six follow-up visits per patient. At each recall visit, all the parameters described above will be measured again, and the record sheet will be reviewed to check compliance. At the final visit, at the end of three months, the parameters will be measured once more, a repeat CBC report will be obtained, and the record sheet will be collected. Any adverse effects reported by participants, such as irritation from the gel or discomfort from the appliance, will also be recorded at each visit.

  1. Study Duration, Statistical Analysis and Ethical Considerations 8.1 Study duration The study will be completed within 9 to 12 months after ethical approval. This period includes recruitment of participants, the three-month treatment and follow-up period for each participant, and data analysis and write-up.

8.2 Statistical analysis The findings will be recorded in tabular form and analysed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS). Descriptive statistics will be used to summarise the sociodemographic and clinical characteristics of the participants. Quantitative variables, such as

Being tested
Herbal Formulation, Shekar's appliance, Multivitamin/Mineral supplements, Conventional oral physiotherapy exercises
Keywords
Oral submucous fibrosis, herbal gel, curcumin, Nigella sativa, mouth opening, burning sensation, randomized control trial
Medical subject headings
Oral Submucous Fibrosis, Paresthesia

What participants receive

What participants receive. In a randomised study each person is assigned to one group by chance.

  • Herbal FormulationDrug

    Novel topical herbal gel (Nutrimed Laboratories, Pakistan) combining six antioxidant/anti-inflammatory agents in one formulation: Nigella sativa 1%, tulsi (Ocimum sanctum) 1%, aloe vera 1%, curcumin 1%, lycopene 1% and vitamin E 0.1%, in a carbomer 974P gel base with humectant, stabiliser, preservative, pH adjuster, flavour and water. Unlike single-agent curcumin or aloe vera gels, or oral herbal products such as Oxitard capsules or lycopene, it delivers all six agents together directly onto the affected oral mucosa. Patients apply a thin layer to the affected areas with a clean fingertip three times daily for 3 months, with no food or drink for 30 minutes afterwards. It is self-applied at home, non-invasive and contains no steroid or hyaluronidase. In this study it is used with conventional oral physiotherapy exercises (Group 2) or with Shekar's appliance (Group 4).

  • Shekar's applianceDevice

    Shekar's appliance is a novel removable intraoral physiotherapy appliance for oral submucous fibrosis, first described by Reddy, Shinde and Khare (J Indian Acad Oral Med Radiol, 2021). It applies controlled, standardised stretching to the fibrotic oral tissues and muscles of mastication to gradually increase mouth opening. Unlike conventional stick exercises with wooden tongue depressors, which depend on the patient's own effort and technique, the appliance gives consistent, repeatable stretching. It needs no electrical equipment (unlike therapeutic ultrasound) and is non-invasive (unlike intralesional injections or surgery). Each patient is trained to insert, use and clean the appliance, and uses it at home three times daily for 15 minutes per session for 3 months. Technique is checked at each 15-day follow-up visit. In this study it replaces conventional exercises and is combined with Pentovit H (Group 3) or the novel herbal gel (Group 4).

  • Multivitamin/Mineral supplementsDietary supplement

    Pentovit H, a commercially available oral multivitamin tablet, used as the conventional medical therapy for oral submucous fibrosis. Multivitamin supplementation is standard care because deficiencies of iron, vitamin B12 and folate are thought to contribute to disease progression. Participants take one tablet twice daily, in the morning and at night after meals, for 3 months. Unlike the novel herbal gel in this study, which is applied directly onto the oral mucosa, Pentovit H is taken by mouth and acts systemically. It contains no herbal extracts, steroids or antifibrotic agents. It is self-administered at home and is a low-cost product widely available in Pakistan. In this study it is the medication component of the conventional arm, combined with physiotherapy exercises (Group 1), and is also combined with Shekar's appliance (Group 3).

  • Conventional oral physiotherapy exercisesOther

    Conventional home-based oral physiotherapy programme for oral submucous fibrosis, made up of seven exercises: stick (wooden tongue depressor) exercise, alphabet exercise, cheek-pushing exercise, balloon-blowing exercise, finger-snap exercise, isometric jaw exercise, and hot-pack massage of the cheeks. Together they stretch the fibrotic buccal tissues and muscles of mastication, improve cheek flexibility and help increase mouth opening. Participants are shown each exercise at the first visit and perform the full routine three times daily for 30 minutes per session for 3 months, with technique checked at each 15-day follow-up. Unlike Shekar's appliance, the exercises need no special device and rely on the patient's own effort, using simple items such as tongue depressors and balloons. In this study the exercises are the physiotherapy component of the conventional arm with Pentovit H (Group 1), and are also combined with the novel herbal gel (Group 2).

Study groups in NCT07921082
Study groupRoleWhat they receive
Conventional exercises + multivitaminActive comparatorFully conventional; Patients do a set of physiotherapy exercises three times a day for 30 minutes each time. The set includes stick, alphabet, cheek-pushing, balloon-blowing, finger-snap and isometric exercises, plus hot-pack massage. They also take Pentovit H twice daily, in the morning and at night after meals. This is standard practice, and the other three arms are compared against it.
Receives: Dietary Supplement: Multivitamin/Mineral supplements; Other: Conventional oral physiotherapy exercises
Conventional exercises + herbal gelExperimentalPatients do the same exercise routine as Group 1, but use the herbal gel instead of the multivitamin. The gel contains 1% each of Nigella sativa, tulsi, aloe vera, curcumin and lycopene, plus 0.1% vitamin E. They apply it three times a day and avoid food and drink for 30 minutes afterwards. Since the exercises match Group 1, comparing the two groups shows whether the gel works better than the multivitamin.
Receives: Drug: Herbal Formulation; Other: Conventional oral physiotherapy exercises
Shekar's appliance + multivitaminExperimentalPatients use Shekar's intraoral appliance three times a day for 15 minutes each time, instead of doing the exercises. They take Pentovit H as in Group 1. Since the medication matches Group 1, comparing the two groups shows whether the appliance works better than the exercises.
Receives: Device: Shekar's appliance; Dietary Supplement: Multivitamin/Mineral supplements
Shekar's appliance + herbal gel (fully contemporary)ExperimentalFully contemporary; Patients use both new treatments: the appliance three times a day for 15 minutes, and the gel three times a day. Comparing this group with Group 1 shows whether the full new approach beats the full conventional one.
Receives: Drug: Herbal Formulation; Device: Shekar's appliance

What is being measured

The primary outcome is the main question the study is designed to answer.

  1. Mouth opening

    Mouth opening (interincisal distance)

    What it shows: how far the patient can open their mouth. This is the main functional outcome, and it also sets the Haider functional stage.

    Tool: vernier caliper.

    How to measure:

    1. Seat the patient upright with the head supported.
    2. Ask them to open as wide as they can without pain.
    3. Measure from the incisal edge of the upper central incisor to the incisal edge of the lower central incisor.
    4. Use the same pair of teeth at every visit. Unit: millimetres. Improvement: the number goes up.

    Measured: Measured at baseline and every 15 days for 3 months

  2. Burning sensation

    What it shows: how severe the patient's burning feels. It is the earliest symptom of the inflammation in OSMF.

    Tool: Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), a 10 cm line from 0 (no burning) to 10 (worst burning imaginable).

    How to measure: ask the patient to mark how much burning they feel, then read the score off the line. Some studies give spicy food as a challenge first; if you do this, use the same challenge at every visit.

    Unit: score from 0 to 10. Improvement: the score goes down

    Measured: Measured at baseline and every 15 days for 3 months

  3. Cheek flexibility

    What it shows: how elastic the buccal mucosa is, which drops as fibrous bands form.

    Tool: vernier caliper or divider, plus a skin marker.

    How to measure:

    Mark V1 at the angle of the mouth. Draw an imaginary line from V1 to the tragus of the ear, and mark V2 one-third of the way along it.

    Measure V1 to V2 with the patient at rest. Ask the patient to blow out their cheeks fully, and measure V1 to V2 again. Cheek flexibility is the blown measurement minus the resting measurement. Unit: millimetres. Improvement: the difference gets bigger.

    Measured: Measured at baseline and every 15 days for 3 months

  4. Tongue protrusion

    What it shows: how freely the tongue moves. Fibrosis of the tongue and floor of the mouth limits this.

    Tool: vernier caliper or a measuring scale.

    How to measure:

    1. Ask the patient to stick the tongue out as far as they can.
    2. Viewing from the side, measure from the incisal edges of the lower front teeth to the tip of the tongue.

    Unit: millimetres. Improvement: the number goes up.

    Measured: Measured at baseline and every 15 days for 3 months

Timeline

From the start of the study to its completion; the mark is today. Estimated dates are the sponsor’s plan.

  1. First posted6 Nov 2026
  2. Study start15 Nov 2026 (estimated)
  3. Primary completion15 Feb 2027 (estimated)
  4. Study completion28 Feb 2027 (estimated)

Resources

More details

For doctors and researchers: how the study is designed, who runs it, and its registry IDs.

Study design
Study type
Interventional
Phase
Phase 2
Primary purpose
Treatment
Allocation
Randomised
Intervention model
Parallel groups
Masking
None (open label)
Enrolment
20 participants (estimated)
IDs, dates and publications
ClinicalTrials.gov ID
NCT07921082
Sponsor's protocol ID
DUHS/IRB/EXTENSION/2023/466
Status last verified
Nov 2026
First submitted
2 Nov 2026
Last updated
6 Nov 2026
Results posted
No
Data monitoring committee
No
FDA-regulated drug
No
FDA-regulated device
No
Individual data sharing
Undecided

Publications

  • Waghmare M, Pagare S, Bhor K, Srivastava R, Manoj R, Gavand K. Comparing efficacy of curcumin with other treatment modalities in oral submucous fibrosis management - A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Ayurveda Integr Med. 2024 Jul-Aug;15(4):100950. doi: 10.1016/j.jaim.2024.100950. Epub 2024 Jul 9.

    PubMed 38986267
  • Chen X, Xie H, Guo J. Drug treatment for oral submucous fibrosis: an update. BMC Oral Health. 2023 Oct 12;23(1):748. doi: 10.1186/s12903-023-03488-9.

    PubMed 37828490
  • Haider SM, Merchant AT, Fikree FF, Rahbar MH. Clinical and functional staging of oral submucous fibrosis. Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2000 Feb;38(1):12-5. doi: 10.1054/bjom.1999.0062.

    PubMed 10783440

Questions about this trial

What is this clinical trial studying?

A Phase 2 study testing Herbal Formulation, Shekar's appliance and Multivitamin/Mineral supplements in people with Oral and Maxillofacial Conditions, run by Dow University of Health Sciences at 1 site in Pakistan.

The full registered description is in the About this study section and the official record.

Who may be eligible to take part?

The sponsor lists 2 inclusion and 3 exclusion criteria. Eligibility is decided by the study team after screening, so read the full criteria and contact a listed site.

Is this clinical trial currently recruiting?

The record says: opening soon, as of the sponsor's last update on 6 Nov 2026. Status can change between updates, so confirm with the study contact before making plans.

Where is the study taking place?

The record lists 1 site in Pakistan. Whether a site is taking part right now should be confirmed with that site. See every site.

What are the possible benefits and risks?

They depend on the study and the treatment, and no study can promise a benefit. The study team explains the known risks during informed consent, before anyone joins; the record itself does not list them.

What does this phase mean?

Phase 2 studies give the treatment to a larger group to see whether it has the intended effect and to keep checking safety.

Not every study follows the same path, and some studies (observational studies, device studies) have no phase.

Are results available for this study?

This study is still under way. Results are not available in the source record yet.

How can a doctor refer a patient or contact the research team?

Contact Ramsha Azhar, BDS, MDS Resident (0092 21 111 113 847, ramsha.azhar@duhs.edu.pk), or a site near the patient. AzTrials does not enrol participants or take referrals.

What does the primary outcome measure?

Mouth opening (time frame: Measured at baseline and every 15 days for 3 months). The study lists 4 primary outcomes in all. It is what the study was designed to measure, not a finding.

Where can I read the original study information?

On the ClinicalTrials.gov record for NCT07921082, which also lists 3 linked publications.

Does a listing mean the treatment is approved or proven to work?

No. A listing means the study is registered. It does not show that the treatment is safe, works, or is approved by a regulator.

How often is this information updated?

AzTrials copies changed records from ClinicalTrials.gov every night and reloads the whole registry every week. The sponsor last updated this record on 6 Nov 2026.

Free account

Log in to keep searching

You’ve used your 3 free searches. AzTrials is free: log in or create a free account to keep searching clinical trials and save the ones you want to follow.

Create a free accountLog in