Study Comparing Hemiarch Replacement and Hemiarch Plus Stent Implantation in Acute Aortic Dissection

Project Objectives

1. To compare the occurrence of Distal Anastomosis New Entry (DANE) after conventional hemiarch replacement group (Hemiarch-C) and the hemiarch replacement plus AMDS implantation group (Hemiarch-AMDS).
2. To compare the rate of all-cause mortality and aortic related mortality (at 30 days, 3-6, 12 months follow-up) between the study groups
3. To compare the rate of patients who are free from the following Major Adverse Events (MAEs) (new permanent disabling stroke, new permanent (> 30 days) paraplegia or paraparesis, reintervention, all-cause mortality) (at 12 months follow-up)
4. To compare radiological outcomes in terms of the rate of stenosis in supra-aortic head vessels, increasing (≥ 5 mm), stable or decreasing (≥ 5 mm) in true lumen in in both groups (at 3-6, 12 months follow-up).
5. To compare the radiological outcomes in terms of obliterated, completely thrombosed, partially thrombosed, or patent false lumen at various segments of aorta in both groups (at 3-6, 12 months follow-up).Thoracic aortic aneurysms (TAAs) and their complications (i.e. dissection, rupture, etc.) cause more than 1400 hospital admissions and 300 deaths every year in Hong Kong. Acute aortic dissection involving the ascending thoracic aorta is a highly lethal surgical emergency that warrants immediate surgical intervention. It can be classified according to DeBakey classification (DeBakey Type I, II, or III). The ascending thoracic aorta is involved in DeBakey Type I and II aortic dissections. In DeBakey Type I (ATAD), the aortic arch and descending thoracic aorta are also involved in the dissection process, therefore conventional hemiarch replacement is only considered "palliative".

Data from international registries showed the mortality of surgically treated ATAD was around 17-26% and those with mal-perfusion had even higher mortality. A significant number of patients of ATAD after conventional hemiarch replacement still have a persistent pressurized false lumen and this is related to the presence of distal anastomotic new entry (DANE).The presence of DANE leads to persistent pulsatile flow and pressurization of the false lumen in 70% of cases after hemiarch replacement.The persistently patent FL will in turn cause mal-perfusion, the need for aortic re-intervention involving the aortic arch, and, most importantly, reduced long-term survival by up to 50%.

To avoid the occurrence of DANE and downstream aortic mal-perfusion, Bozso and colleagues advocated the use of a novel Ascyrus Medical Dissection Stent (AMDS; Artivion, Atlanta, Georgia, US) hybrid prosthesis which comprises a proximal sewing collar and a distal self-expanding nitinol un-covered stent. From a prospective trial utilizing AMDS in ATAD, the Dissected Aorta Repair Through Stent Implantation (DARTS) trial, by Boszo and colleagues, the positive remodeling of the aortic arch occurred in 100% of cases with complete obliteration or thrombosis of the false lumen in 74%. In their series of 47 patients, there was no DANE after the AMDS implantation.

Work done by the principal investigator's unit is a major referral center for acute and complex aortic disease in Hong Kong, with more than 100 cases of operated aortic cases and 200 aortic referrals each year. The investigator's unit also operated on an average of 40-50 cases of ATAD each year.

The incidence of DANE in the investigator's unit is 19.5% from a retrospective reviewed of the institution's ATAD patients who received hemiarch replacement from Jan 2017 to Dec 2021. Although the incidence of DANE is lower than the reported literature, given the presence of DANE will significantly increase the risk of long-term mortality. The investigators believe a randomized control trial to compare the incidence of DANE after hemiarch replacement with or without AMDS implantation in ATAD can answer our research question and potentially be practice-changing.

Main research question is to compare the incidence of DANE after hemiarch replacement with or without AMDS implantation in acute DeBakey Type I aortic dissection.

Research methods Study Design: Single-center randomized control trial Methodology In this study, the investigators plan to prospectively recruit consecutive patients with acute DeBakey Type I aortic dissection and randomized them, after informed consent, into either the conventional hemiarch replacement group (Hemiarch-C) or the hemiarch replacement plus AMDS implantation group (Hemiarch-AMDS). The participating team will collect pre-operative, intra-operative, and post-operative clinical and radiological parameters for two groups of patients. Written informed consent, specifically allowing the use of clinical records for this randomized study, will be obtained from every patient prior to data collection. The period of data collection will be from the first recruited patient to 12 months after the last recruited patient, which will be around 36 months. Source data verification will be performed on 100% of the patients; data from all the visits that were provided in the database will be reviewed and verified against existing source documents by a dedicated research assistant. Complete DICOM image files of the CT scans will be evaluated by two independent fully qualified Radiologists. The expected patient loss rate is approximately 5% at 12 months of follow-up.

Study population Screening and randomization A computer-generated randomization sequence will be generated by the research assistant using the online randomization software. A total of 72 patients will be randomized 1:1 to one of the two treatment arms. Block randomization with block size of 8 is used to maintain good balance in each treatment group. The randomization list will be kept in a set of tamper-evident envelopes. The envelopes will be identical and sealed. The trial identifier with a sequential number will be printed on each envelope and the inside will contain the treatment allocation. Envelopes will be unsealed by the on-call surgeon to reveal the allocation treatment prior to the surgery.

Patients, with their consent, will be recruited to participate by investigators after considering the inclusion and exclusion criteria.

Blinding of the study After randomization, the recruited patient will be allocated to either AMDS or Hemiarch group. There will be no blinding of the randomization result to the recruited patients, the operating surgeons, and the clinician-in-charge.

Pre-treatment Investigations and Assessments:

1. Blood tests: complete blood count, liver and renal function tests, coagulation profile
2. Radiological imaging: CT aortogram involving the thorax and abdomen
3. ECG and/or other cardiac assessment as requested by anesthetist for general anesthesia assessment Treatment Procedures

Hemiarch-AMDS group:

Under general anesthesia and trans-esophageal echocardiogram monitoring, a median sternotomy will be performed. Patients will be put on cardiopulmonary bypass with arterial inflow from femoral artery/axillary artery/direct aortic cannulation and right atrial appendage venous two-stage cannulation. Systemic cooling to 25 Degree Celsius will commence. At a temperature of 25 Degree Celsius and thiopentone coma, the circulatory arrest will begin. The aorta will be trimmed to the level of the distal ascending or proximal arch The AMDS device will be implanted into the aortic arch and descending thoracic aorta. The distal anastomosis will be done between a vascular graft and the distal ascending aorta/aortic arch including the AMDS device sewing cuff. After the distal anastomosis is completed, visceral and cerebral systemic perfusion and rewarming will be started. The proximal ascending aorta will be anastomosed with the proximal end of the vascular graft. After de-airing and aorta will be de-clamped and the patient will be weaned from cardiopulmonary bypass and decannulated. Hemostasis and sternal closure will be done as per routine protocol.

Hemiarch-C group:

Same as above except no AMDS is implanted. The perioperative management of all recruited patients is standardized. All patients receive prophylactic antibiotics during induction and until all drains are removed in the postoperative period. All patients will have invasive blood pressure monitoring with an arterial line and intravenous antihypertensive medications aiming to control systolic blood pressure to below 140mmHg.

Sample size calculation The occurrence of DANE was estimated to be around 70% and it caused persistent false lumen perfusion, mal-perfusion, early mortality, and decreased long-term survival. From a prospective trial by Moon and colleagues, the positive remodeling of the aortic arch occurred in 100% of cases with complete obliteration or thrombosis of the false lumen in 74%. In their series of 47 patients, there was no DANE after the AMDS implantation. Our own unpublished cohort of 167 cases revealed the occurrence of DANE in 19.5% after our hemiarch procedures. Based on a previous report and our own cohort of DANE rate of 19.5% and 70% respectively, and assumed DANE rate of 0% after AMDS, 36 patients need to be recruited for each arm (a total of 72 patients) in order to demonstrate a statistically significant difference with an 80% power at the 0.05 level of 1-sided significant difference between Hemiarch-AMDS and Hemiarch-C by a superiority time-to-event study design.

Data analysis Statistical analysis will be performed using SPSS version 28.0.0.0 (IBM, NewYork, USA) on an intention-to-treat basis. The primary analysis set for statistical reporting will be the ITT population with no replacement of missing data planned in the statistical analysis to provide unbiased results. Missing data will be checked, and the imputation of the missing data will be used to preserve statistical power. The investigators will use the log-rank test to compare the time from randomization to the endpoints of occurrence of DANE. A Cox proportional-hazards model to estimate the hazard ratio and 95% confidence intervals. The investigators will use Schoenfeld residual test to verify the assumption of proportional hazards in the Cox analysis, to fulfill the endpoint of the occurrence of DANE. Secondary endpoints will be compared between groups with a chi-square test for difference in proportions with student's t-test and a Mann-Whitney U test for parametric and non-parametric data, respectively. All tests of significance were two-tailed, and a P value of 0.05 or less will be considered to indicate statistical significance for the primary endpoint. Percentages will be calculated on the number of non-missing observations. When applicable, bilateral asymptotic or exact confidence intervals (CIs) for binomial distributions will be calculated at the 95% level (unadjusted 95% CI). For analysis of data where the outcome variable is the time until the occurrence of an event of interest (for example, death, myocardial infarction etc.), the non-parametric estimator of these survival functions will be presented using the Kaplan-Meier method, together with a graphical presentation.

The investigator's unit operate on an average of 40-50 cases of acute aortic dissection each year. Assuming DeBakey Type I (ATAD) constitutes around 87% of all acute aortic dissection and acceptance of study by patients of 90%. It is therefore expected that recruitment can be completed in about 24 months. The last recruited patient will be observed for at least 12 months after the procedure. Hence, the total period of study including follow-up is 3 years, which is also the funding period for the grant application. After completion of the funding period, the recruited patients will be followed up to 2 years with interval investigations with CT scans to assess the aortic remodeling of both groups.

All clinical data will be collected in the principal investigator's center by a dedicated research assistant. Continuous clinical data monitoring and interim and final analysis will be performed by the principal investigator and co-investigators with the help of a research assistant.

Ethical consideration This study shall be conducted in accordance with the ethical principles in the Declaration of Helsinki. This protocol is approved by the Joint Chinese University of Hong Kong and New Territories East Cluster Clinical Research Ethics Committees (CREC:2023.075-T)). Written informed consent, specifically allowing the use of clinical records for study purposes, will be obtained from every patient prior to data collection.

Patients can withdraw from the study without any prejudice at any time during the study. Data will be kept confidential in secure offices of the Department of Surgery for seven years.

Potential risks of the study Acute aortic dissection is a life-threatening emergency condition with mortality of around 17-26% from the world registries. In the principal investigator unit, from a retrospective record review of 2017-2021, the investigator's center has 167 Acute aortic dissection. Among this cohort, there was 87.1% of patients with DeBakey Type I (ATAD). Our operative mortality for ATAD is 4.3%. The incidence of DANE in our patients is 19.5%. According to the DARTS trial, the placement of AMDS device increases circulatory arrest time by an average of 3 minutes with 100% technical success rate. The implantation of AMDS is simple and much more generalizable than the complicated TARFET. The investigators do not anticipate there will be any increase in mortality or morbidity with AMDS implantation.